Enough is enough! Japanese and U.S. manga publishers have just about had it with illegal "scanlation aggregator" websites that are hosting thousands of pirated manga titles, many of them already licensed in English, and making easy money at the creators' expense. All the while, legit manga publishers are forced to decimate their staff or even shut down business due to plunging sales, as manga fans nowadays have unrestricted access to pretty much any title, even on mobile devices.
Through a joint press release yesterday, a slew of Japanese and U.S. publishers announced the formation of a multi-national manga anti-piracy coalition, in a "coordinated effort to combat a rampant and growing problem of internet piracy plaguing the manga industry". Participants in the coalition include the 36 members of Japan's Digital Comic Association, joined by Square Enix, Viz Media, Tokyopop, Vertical, Yen Press and the Tuttle-Mori Agency.
These 42 companies have so far identified 30 sites targeted for "aggressive action". They haven't given any names yet, but a spokesperson for the coalition said that they are giving such offending websites a chance to lay down arms peacefully. Otherwise, they are threatened with a legal gangbang, with the participation of such painful guests as the Justice Department and the FBI.
"It is unfortunate that this action has become necessary", said a spokesperson for the group. "However, to protect the intellectual property rights of our creators and the overall health of our industry, we are left with no other alternative but to take aggressive action. It is our sincere hope that offending sites will take it upon themselves to immediately cease their activities. Where this is not the case, however, we will seek injunctive relief and statutory damages. We will also report offending sites to federal authorities, including the anti-piracy units of the Justice Department, local law enforcement agencies and FBI."
Publishers Weekly offers more background information about the 40-year-old practice of scanlating manga, and how this formerly fan-driven activity has become such a huge deal, especially in the last two years of free-falling manga sales in the U.S.
"Go back 2 years and track these sites and you’ll find an inverse relationship between the rise of traffic on these scanlation sites and the decline in U.S. manga sales", said Kurt Hassler, publishing director of Yen Press.
It's interesting to observe how this news comes soon after one such illegal scanlation aggregator website, OneManga, was spotted in the top 1000 most-visited sites on the web according to Google, with an estimated 4.2 million unique visitors and 1.1 billion page views. Liek... gief!
Unrelated to all this, the Japanese publisher Kadokawa (who of course is among those 36 members of Japan's Digital Comic Association) has withdrawn a recently released light novel called Ore to Kanojo ga Maoh to Yusha de Seitokaicho (under the Dengeki Bunko imprint), due to it plagiarizing the more popular light novels Baka to Test to Shoukanjuu. The second anime season of BakaTest is only coming in 2011, by the way.
sites like OneManga are hosting sites.
why dont they target the actual scanners?
then no need to worry about hosting sites.
Stokkywrote on Jun 11, 2010 at 16:27
Well it's easier to target only a few bigger ones (who draw in most of the piracy anyway), than start picking on small groups / individuals who are maybe scanlating 1-2 series only. Besides, such groups / individuals usually abandon their projects when something gets licensed, or are formally asked to do so.
I saw one such post on the OneManga forum (or maybe it was on MangaFox) right after this news came out, with one scanlator actually asking the website to remove his scanlations in light of this announcement.
Plus the "coalition" can build stronger cases when they can pile up accusations from tens of publishers at the same time, against a single entity who is liable for much more $$$ in damages.
Stokkywrote on Jun 11, 2010 at 18:04
Oh and small scanlators are like mosquitoes: you smash one, two more fly in the room.
ShoujinBoywrote on Jun 12, 2010 at 12:23
hmmm i guess so. i just thought that hosting sites would have the same metaphoric analysis. i mean theres so many of them too. although yes definitly much larger scale between the tiny ones and big ones.
yeah i thought about the whole suing for multiple damages, a while after i posted sorry. makes suing the smaller scanners insignificant in comparison.
anonymouswrote on Jun 20, 2010 at 07:08
They shouldn't target scanlators. One reason stated as to why they're closing down manga sites is because they're using the said sites for profit. (i.e. ads and asking money before you're able to view or download the manga.)
anonymouswrote on Jul 23, 2010 at 15:12
Some Country's Don't Have Manga !!!!!!
anonymouswrote on Jul 23, 2010 at 15:15
OH ya that is right !
the people who read manga in the country's that dont have them wont be able to read them , or buy them , and that will be a huge problem from them ! :(
( people who use the sites cuz no manga in their country )
anonymouswrote on Jul 24, 2010 at 15:02
Its nice that they are going to try and shut down the sites that make a profit off of their works, but what will happen to all the people who use sites like onemanga to find what new out there and what is worth while to buy. I didn't even know 98% of the great mangas like Reborn, History's Strongest Disciple Kenichi, or Gantz out there when I first started. Now I buy them all the time.
anonymouswrote on Jul 24, 2010 at 22:40
I find Mr. Kurt's line very amusing because well...to be frank, if you want to then you can calculate any correlation you want with the proper amount of data manipulation so .... yeah.... sorry wont believe you :P
Actually, I'll say that if you check the numbers, most people got into manga in the first place thanks to the efforts of the scanlators. I mean honestly, most of em dont have access to the expensive US translated mangas and to wait 2-3 months on the minimum for a new volume, while wishing and praying that it wont be delayed is more than can be handled. And lets not forget the weird titles...who picks them? who approves them? D:
Jul-chanwrote on Jul 29, 2010 at 11:14
Well it's a 50/50 thing for me regarding manga sites. I wouldn't have purchased the manga available if it wasn't for such sites. Yet, there are people who have the means to purchase manga, but they are too cheap to do so. Now great sites like Onemanga are being shut down... I think publishers should have sites where you can read manga online with a small fee. It'll still be under their control and us honest people can still get our manga fix.
anonymouswrote on Jul 31, 2010 at 06:49
I've read entire series-or at least as much is as out, on OneManga before, and I can understand that they'd want to put a stop to that, but I'm not buying any more manga because they're shuting down the site. I'll probably be buying less because now I have nowhere to check out a manga to see if I like it. I'm not going to go shelf read at a book store whenever I get a recomendation, and like hell I'll just buy a manga without checking it out.
Besides, the manga I read online without buying our ones I wouldn't waste money on anyway-I'm just passing time with them. I don't care too much if I can't read them any more, I'll just check a book out of the library.
Any manga I read online that I felt was worth purchasing I did purchase (or am saving up to purchase) but the english volumes are way behind so I read online while waiting for the next volume to be released. I support authors I actually like, but now I'll be stuck waiting 4 years to find out what happens next in my favorite manga.
anonymouswrote on Jul 31, 2010 at 07:11
There's a site that just has some of the most recently released chapters from japan. Each time it adds a new chapter to any story it removes the oldest. Maybe they could allow sites to show the material not yet released in the US, if they insist on continuing to remain so far behind japan.
anonymouswrote on Aug 4, 2010 at 17:11
I can see it now. A decrease of manga fans. How sad..... IMHO one reason why manga becomes so popular now a days are due to this Scanlation sites.
Problems regarding manga readers from other country's:
1. No sellers(availability)
2. Have sellers but delayed with jap manga.
3. Manga like bleach naruto and any other famous manga are the only one's get published or sold outside japan.
Suggestion to manga publishers:
1. Make a pay site to be able to view your mangas.
2. For the newly manga title you should offer 1-5 chapters free viewing. No one would like to spend their money on something they are not sure if it would be interesting.
t
anonymouswrote on Aug 31, 2010 at 05:36
I live in Florida. There are no book stores that have any of the manga titles i read in stock and even the major ones like Naruto are not there. American publishers vastly fail in supplying the masses with the manga they read. I Would mail money to the authors of the manga i read if i knew the money would get to them i tried once and im not sure if the check ever got cashed. WE NEED THE MANGA. If it wasnt for scanlations i would have never found a great deal of the manga i know about because its simply not published here or if it is its rare and hard to find.
anonymouswrote on Jan 16, 2011 at 02:39
i read manga on the site cause in my country they dont sell theme and i dont have any were else to read manga if they sell theme here i would be the first one to buy
why dont they target the actual scanners?
then no need to worry about hosting sites.